Part I of this series explained that a global fiscal crisis is likely because of reckless increases in the burden of government spending.
Part II of the series speculated that France might be the country that triggers the crisis.
Today, in Part III, we’re going to look at whether the crisis might start in the United Kingdom. And we’ll being with the same chart we used yesterday, but this time with 2000-2026 IMF data for the United Kingdom.
The good news is that the burden of government spending in the United Kingdom is less than 44 percent of GDP compared to more than 57 percent of GDP in France.
The bad news is that the spending burden is growing much faster in the United Kingdom, with government this century consuming an extra 9 percent of GDP, compared to an increased fiscal burden in France of about 5 percent of GDP.
As a result of these different trends, government debt has tripled in the U.K. while it has “only” doubled in France.
In other words, the U.K.’s fiscal data doesn’t look horrible compared to France, but the U.K. is going in the wrong direction at a faster rate.
No wonder that the country is also on the wrong side of the interest rate/growth divide.
I’m not the only once to notice the bad news. Let’s review portions of a recent Wall Street Journaleditorial.
Andy Burnham became the seventh British prime minister in a decade…, and good luck getting British finances…sorted. …the ever-expanding welfare state will constrict the choices of anyone who tries to govern. During the 2025-26 fiscal year, the U.K. spent £407.3 billion (some $543 billion) on old-age benefits, disability payouts and other welfare, according to Treasury’s new statistics. That’s a nominal increase of 5.4% in a single year… Spending on welfare for children and working-age adults claiming a disability in the last fiscal year was £66 billion, up from £44 billion in fiscal 2019-2020. Blame an explosion in doubtful claims for mental-health conditions such as depression and ADHD. This has become an enormous economic and social drag as millions of people abandon the workforce and become wards of the state. These numbers don’t include the fiscal burden that the National Health Service imposes. Treasury says British spending on health hit £257.5 billion last year. Think of this British version of Medicare for All as a black hole for money and the nation’s health, as six million patients languish on waiting lists and the system delivers terrible cancer survival rates and other outcomes relative to European peers with more market-oriented systems. …Britain is a case study in how expansive social welfare subsumes government budgets and makes countries less prosperous and less secure.
A Washington Posteditorial is similarly pessimistic.
Here are the key passages.
The “new path” proposed by British Prime Minister Andy Burnham in his debut speech at the Labour Party’s annual conference last week sounds a lot like the one that led the United Kingdom into prolonged stagnation. …Burnham dedicated his much-anticipated speech to visions of a bigger government, more public ownership and more spending on entitlements that Britain cannot afford. …Borrowing costs hit their highest levels since 1998…, when 30-year gilt yields tipped over 6 percent. The government has little room to maneuver. …Britain spent almost twice as much on debt service as on defense in the past fiscal year.
Here are some excerpts from a column in the Scotsman by Paul Wilson.
The national debt is just shy of £3 trillion and rising – almost 100 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP). That is more than three times the rate it was 25 years ago, the last time any British government ran a surplus. …Last year saw a £130 billon deficit, meaning that for every £10 the government took in revenue, it spent roughly £11. …International markets are starting to take note. Global investors – foreign governments, central banks, pension funds and insurers – are increasingly concerned about UK sovereign debt. We are losing their confidence, which is why the government borrowing rate is the highest on record. The £4.25bn sale earlier this month of 30-year bonds drew a yield of 5.82 per cent – the highest for any bond sale since the Debt Management Office was created nearly 30 years ago. The average yield on newly sold UK debt has been stuck at a 30-year high for the past two years. The Tories left the economy in a terrible state two years ago, but Labour has only succeeded in making things even worse. …We desperately need to rein in spending… Burnham and his team appear to belong to the ostrich school of macroeconomics, which teaches that you should bury your head in the sand and hope for the best
Interestingly, France and the U.K. are in trouble for different reasons.
Spending is growing too fast in both nations, of course, but the main problem in France is their version of Social Security. By contrast, as noted in a study for the Fraser Institute, old-age retirement spending in the U.K. is barely half of the French level.
A big problem in the United Kingdom is welfare programs.
Here are some sobering passages from a recent report by Max Colchester and David Luhnow in the Wall Street Journal.
Disability payouts are no longer just for those most in need; they have become a financial crutch for a large swath of the population… It’s blowing up Britain’s welfare bill, hamstringing its politicians and imperiling its long-term financial stability. Some seven million people—more than 10% of the population—now claim at least one or more sickness or disability benefits. The numbers are growing fastest among working-age people who should be powering the country’s economy, surging more than 60% in the past six years to 4.7 million from 2.9 million in 2019. Not including healthcare, the country will spend more than £100 billion this year on all types of welfare benefits for the sick and disabled, about a third more than defense spending. The tab has surged by a quarter in just four years and is on course to hit £130 billion in the next four… One benefit, created to help those with disabilities be more mobile, allows people to give up part of their welfare cash handout in return for a new car lease every three years. It now accounts for around one in every seven new car sales in the U.K. Among those who got new cars last year: 40 people whose primary medical condition was tennis elbow, 50 with wheat intolerance and 320 with dyslexia, according to government figures.
Here’s a chart from the story.
As you can see, there is an unsustainable rate of growth for redistribution outlays.
Needless to say, when you pay people not to work, you get less productive activity.
Meanwhile, the growing spending burden leads to ever-higher taxes on the people who are pulling the wagon.
Yet this creates an awful incentive system, as captured by this visual.
P.S. If you want some horrific examples of British welfare dependency, click here, here, here, here, and here. There’s even a British TV program about mooching.
P.P.S. And don’t forget that the U.K.’s government-run health system is a fiscal nightmare.