Part II of the Global Entitlement Crisis: Will France Be the First Domino?

by Dan Mitchell | Oct 12, 2026

For this week’s series on the global entitlement crisis, we’re going to begin each column by looking at key fiscal policy developments during the 21st century.

And, to make sure we’re using consistent numbers, we’ll use the International Monetary Fund’s World Economic Outlook database for each example.

We’ll start with France.

For every country, I’ll calculate the average growth of government spending and then make comparisons to average growth of inflation and population.

In the case of France, it started the century with too much government (more than 52 percent of GDP) and things have gone from bad to worse. The spending burden has increased and the debt burden has exploded.

And an exploding debt burden makes the “bond vigilantes” nervous. Which means they demand higher interest rates to compensate for the risk of default.

And that’s exactly what we see in France.

Unless something changes, France is doomed to suffer a Greek-style crisis.

I’m not the only pessimist. Here are some excerpts from a Washington Post editorial.

The sick man of Europe is now France, beset by a combination of sky-high welfare spending, swelling deficits and a looming debt bomb. The nation’s fiscal woes threaten to spread economic turbulence across the euro zone. …Hedge funds, foreign governments and pension funds have been dumping long-term French government bonds, pushing the 10-year yield over 5 percent. The bond sell-off is symptomatic of the larger problem. Investors are skittish because France’s overall fiscal picture looks increasingly grim, and its fractious political system seems incapable of preventing the country from drifting toward default. …France’s problem is simple: The country spends more to support its extravagant social safety net and its sprawling government bureaucracy than it collects in taxes. The country spends more than 57 percent of its gross domestic product on the public sector, higher even than European counterparts, who are not exactly stingy with entitlement spending. …The last time France had a balanced budget was 1974. It was inevitable that the bill would eventually come due. Investors are signaling that the reckoning may be fast approaching.

Hans van Leeuwen, the International Economics Editor for the U.K.-based Telegraph, is equally pessimistic.

Here are some relevant passages from his column.

Investors…don’t see a country planning to live within its means. So they have driven French bond yields – the cost of government borrowing – to the highest level in decades. This has pushed the “spread” between French and German bond yields to levels that have prompted fears of a wider eurozone crisis – one that could rope in the European Central Bank (ECB) and set the whole bloc on fire. …Some big Japanese holders of French bonds have already headed for the exit. If the exodus can’t be stopped, the ECB may have to start buying French bonds to stem the soaring yields and head off a bloc-wide crisis. But if the ECB steps in, bond vigilantes will be primed to test the central bank’s resolve. The ensuing crisis could spill into other heavily indebted countries, such as Belgium or Italy. …the bond markets are ultimately going to tame France or break it.

Here are two charts from the column.

The first once confirms that France’s problem is excessive growth of government spending.

The second chart shows that investors are losing trust in the French government, as measured by the growing gap between interest rates on French and German government debt.

Let’s cite one more article.

Here are excerpts from a column by Daniel Lacalle for Tomorrow’s Affairs.

France is a very rich country, with enormous human, entrepreneurial and financial capital. It also has a predatory state that hinders economic growth, job creation and productivity. France is now confronting a harsh reality. …its fiscal trajectory, weak growth outlook and policy paralysis should be a warning to governments that believe permanent deficits can be treated as a harmless feature of modern economic management. …France’s public spending reached 57.5% of GDP in 2025, the highest ratio in the euro area. Yet higher spending has not produced dynamic growth. The IMF forecasts French real GDP growth of only 0.7% in 2026, following 0.9% in 2025, while the European Commission expects growth of just 0.8% in 2026. …The state is consuming resources that must be financed through continually rising taxation, monetary accommodation, spending cuts or a combination of all three. …France’s problem also demonstrates the limits of a tax-led response to structural deficits. The country already has one of the highest revenue-to-GDP ratios in the euro area. …Higher taxes…reduce returns on investment, discourage entrepreneurship, push capital towards more favourable jurisdictions and make it harder for businesses to expand employment and productive capacity. The impact may not be immediate, but it is inevitable. …France has shown that big government, massive immigration and high taxes generate stagnation, social frustration and a debt burden that eventually forces more painful choices.

Amen.

He correctly points out that the problem is too much spending and that higher taxes would merely pour fuel on the fire.

Here’s one final chart, taken from an article in the Economist, that shows France’s vulnerability to fiscal crisis.

The bottom line is that France desperately needs Milei-style spending restraint in the short run and a Swiss-style spending cap in the long run.

Sadly, given French ideological preferences, there’s very little reason to expect that sober-minded approach.