Most important, at least for purposes of today’s column, I also told the BBC that a corporate tax cartel would be very dangerous since politicians would quickly try to apply the same approach to other types of taxes.
Well, I was right.
As reported in Barron‘s, some of the world’s greediest governments are now pushing a global wealth tax cartel. Here are some excerpts from the story by Daniel Avis.
Brazil, which is chairing the G20 this year, has been pushing for the group of nations which together account for 80 percent of the world’s economy to adopt a shared stance… “Fair international taxation is not just a topic of choice for progressive economists, but a key concern at the very heart of macroeconomic management today,” Brazilian finance minister Fernando Haddad said during an IMF event in Washington. “Without international cooperation, there is a limit to what states can do, both rich and developing ones,” he added. …Sitting alongside Haddad at the IMF event, French finance minister Bruno Le Maire renewed his calls for a global minimum tax… “The future of the world cannot be a race to the bottom,” Le Maire said.
Haddad seems like a not-very-good person. He’s been a political science professor, according to Wikipedia, and he’s authored some publications that suggest he’s a leftist ideologue.
In Defense of Socialism
Theses on Karl Marx
Work and Language for the Renewal of Socialism
This crank is now trying to set tax policy for the entire world!
Marcela Ayres and Andrea Shalal of Reuters also reported on Haddad’s initiative, and their article noted the predictably pernicious role of the International Monetary Fund.
Brazil’s proposal to tax the super-rich globally gained momentum among Group of Twenty members…with France’s finance minister and the head of the International Monetary Fund backing a coordinated push to generate new revenue… IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva said…ensuring that the richest paid their fair share would mobilize funds… She said IMF research…also estimated that setting a minimum floor for carbon pricing could boost revenue by $1.4 trillion a year. …Gabriel Zucman, director of the European Tax Observatory, …has proposed that very-high-net-worth individuals…pay at least the equivalent of 2% of their wealth in income tax each year. That would generate $250 billion per year.
I can’t resist pointing out that Ms. Georgieva (like all IMF bureaucrats) gets a very lavish salary that is exempt from taxation. Yet this hypocritical parasite agitates for higher taxes on everyone else.
Fortunately, at least one major government is skeptical of this money grab.
In a separate report from Reuters, Christian Kraemer and Maria Martinez note that Germany’s Finance Minister is not a fan.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner rejected on Thursday Brazil’s proposal to tax the super-rich, indicating a challenging path for it to gain widespread G20 support. …Speaking after meeting U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders on Thursday, Brazil’s Finance Minister Fernando Haddad said of Lindner’s opposition to the proposal: “He will change (his mind).” Sanders said he “strongly” supports the proposal… But the Brazilian government is aware that other countries like Japan and Italy have shown resistance to the initiative, added the source. …Le Maire said that moving to tax the rich was the logical next step for a series of global taxation reforms launched in 2017, including agreement on a global corporate minimum tax.
Let’s hope Germany holds firm, and that Japan and Italy also are on the right side.
But I worry because the statist countries will be relentless.
Remember, the corporate tax cartel seemed crazy when it was first proposed about 10 years ago. But the left kept pushing and now it’s in the process of being implemented.
I worry the same thing will now happen with a global wealth tax cartel.
P.P.S. It was nice of Monsieur Le Maire to confirm what I told the BBC about the corporate tax cartel being the first step on the path to other tax cartels.
P.P.P.S. I have not bothered to make the economic case against the wealth tax in this column, but feel free to click here, here, here, and here for that type of analysis.
Dan Mitchell is co-founder of the Center for Freedom and Prosperity and Chairman of the Board. He is an expert in international tax competition and supply-side tax policy.
