I periodically warn that the United States is on a path to become a European-style welfare state.
That sounds good to some people since it implies lots of goodies paid for by other people.
So I always explain that there’s a downside. The economic data clearly show that there’s been less growth in Europe and this has real-world consequences.
- Europe is diverging from the United States economically, not converging.
- The average American enjoys much higher levels of income and better quality of life.
- America’s poor people have incomes equal to middle-class Europeans.
This is why it’s so depressing that Joe Biden has a radical agenda of higher tax rates and much bigger government.
He wants us to copy an approach that has produced inferior outcomes.
The editorial page of the Wall Street Journal has been sounding the alarm.
In a recent column, Professor Josef Joffe contemplates the impact of more dependency on America’s economy.
America is the land of “predatory capitalism,” German chancellor Helmut Schmidt liked to say. …President Biden’s tax plans might soon make Europe look like a capitalist heaven by comparison. …The middle class will pay the bill. …Reversing course won’t be easy because gifts, once given, are hard to take back, whether in the U.S. or in Europe. …As government expands and hands out more goodies, it also tightens its grip on the economy. It shrinks the private sector, the engine of U.S. wealth creation. It is no accident that Europe has grown more slowly over the past 40 years as government spending, regulations and taxes have increased.
Prof. Joffe’s point about the durability of entitlements (“once given, are hard to take back”) is vitally important.
This is why it is so important to block Biden’s per-child handouts.
Dan Henninger made similarly important points a couple of months ago.
The club Mr. Biden is joining…is one the U.S. has stayed out of since World War II. That is the club known as the European welfare state. It is the government-directed system of lifetime paternalism built up by the nations of Western Europe after 1945. …Public welfare has never been America’s reason for being, notwithstanding our substantial spending on social support programs. Despite the entitlement creations of FDR’s New Deal and LBJ’s Great Society, the U.S., unlike Europe, has remained a nation driven and led by capitalist initiative. For current-generation Democrats, that fact is anathema. …The March stimulus bill already had one foot inside the economic club of Europe’s door.
For what it’s worth, I’m not quite as positive about the United States as Henninger. Our welfare state is a significant burden, though he is right that it is smaller than the welfare states in Europe.
Let’s not quibble about that point, though, because Henninger has another observation that is spot on.
Biden’s agenda is a recipe for big tax increases on the middle class.
Europe became famous for its perpetual-motion tax machine, which suppressed the continent’s entrepreneurial instincts. Besides income taxes, Europe relies heavily on the collection of notoriously high value-added taxes…total tax revenue from all governments in the U.S. as a percentage of GDP is 24%, compared with an average of more than 40% in seven European nations… Those European tax levels will never fall. Their governments gotta have the money. Mr. Biden purports that his proposed $3 trillion in tax increases hit only corporations and “the wealthiest.” But if his entitlements become law, European levels of middle-class taxation—perhaps a VAT or carbon tax—are inevitable. Mr. Biden’s plans to increase Internal Revenue Service audits lay the groundwork for that.
Amen.
Honest folks on the left openly admit that this is true.
I’ll close with two final points.
First, it would be a mistake to copy Europe’s welfare states, but there are worse things that could happen. Those nations may lag the United States, but they are generally richer than other parts of the world.
But I’m not sure “better than Venezuela” is a persuasive selling point.
Second, because of demographic change and poorly designed entitlement programs, we’re already on a path to become a European welfare state.
But I’m not sure “let’s drive faster over the cliff” is a persuasive selling point.
———
Image credit: Sébastien Bertrand | CC BY 2.0.